Pugh Matrix for DMAIC Improve Phase Solution Selection
PUGH matrix|weightage|comparing alternatives|Ranking|
rkmaths
Pugh Matrix – Solution Selection Tool
The Pugh Matrix is a structured decision-making tool used in the DMAIC Improve Phase of Lean Six Sigma to evaluate and select the most suitable solution from multiple alternatives.
This interactive application enables users to compare 3 to 5 alternative solutions against a selected reference alternative (Datum), using 3 to 7 evaluation criteria.
Users can assign importance weights to individual criteria and evaluate each alternative using three comparison ratings:
↑ Better than Datum (+1)
→ Same as Datum (0)
↓ Worse than Datum (−1)
The application automatically generates the Unweighted Pugh Summary, Weighted Pugh Matrix and Weighted Pugh Summary. It calculates positive scores, negative scores, net scores and rankings to identify the preferred alternative.
The application also provides an automatic decision and conclusion based on the evaluation results, helping project teams make systematic, objective and evidence-based solution selection decisions.
Key Features:
Dynamic alternatives and evaluation criteria.
Reference alternative (Datum) selection.
Customisable importance weights.
Automatic weighted and unweighted calculations.
Comparative summary matrices and ranking.
Automatic decision and conclusion.
CSV export and printable results.
Application: Lean Six Sigma – Black Belt
DMAIC Phase: Improve
Tool: Pugh Matrix and Weighted Pugh Matrix
